Blog

Why I stopped putting one-yen coins in the offering box

I joined a business meeting at a Shinto shrine and got to ask things I never get to ask. The surprise: every one-yen coin in the offering box puts the shrine in the red.

Thoughts

I joined a business meeting at a Shinto shrine. It was my first time visiting a shrine for business, so I asked about many things I never get to ask. Several answers impressed me — here is one of them.

A one-yen offering puts the shrine in the red

At Japanese shrines, visitors toss coins into an offering box (saisen) when they pray. What surprised me: for every one-yen coin offered, the shrine loses money. When the shrine deposits the piles of one-yen coins at a bank, the fee is 550 yen per 500 coins, I was told. That works out to 1.1 yen per coin — more than the coin's face value of 1 yen. The published rates of major Japanese banks match this: depositing 101 to 500 coins at the counter costs 550 yen.

Part of the gesture turns into a fee

People make offerings hoping for good fortune, or wanting to support the shrine and the priests who keep it. Either way, the money is handed over as a gesture toward the deity. If the one-yen portion of that gesture turns into a bank fee and the shrine covers the difference, that is not what the giver intended.

What I decided to do

Since the day I heard this at the shrine, I have stopped putting one-yen coins in the offering box. Lately I put in a 1,000-yen note when I visit. In Japan there is a popular wordplay — a five-yen coin, "go-en", sounds like "good ties" — but a pun has no substance. Offering an amount that actually helps, within your means, seems the truer way to reach the priests — and the deity.

Takeaways

  • One-yen offerings cost the shrine more in deposit fees than their face value.
  • An amount that helps beats a lucky pun. If it is a gesture, let the gesture arrive whole.

← Back to Thoughts All posts